UK wants to defer DeFi taxation

The proposed United Kingdom DeFi tax rules would prevent capital gains tax from accruing on certain lending transactions and liquidity pool transfers until investors make an economic disposal of the assets.

This relief would be narrower than a general tax cut: the terms of the relief, the number of tokens, the income from rewards and the treatment of existing positions would still determine when the bill arrives.

A UK investor could deposit tokens that have risen in value into a DeFi platform without receiving pounds sterling, making purchases, or intending to give up the investment. However, under the current HMRC interpretation, such a transfer could trigger a capital gains tax calculation if the beneficial owner changes.

The government wants to change this outcome for qualifying loans and liquidity pools. Its published tax proposal, first presented in July and updated on October 28, would bring the tax regime closer to the economic outcomes of the arrangement.

The anticipated commencement date of the law is April 6, 2027, subject to its adoption. Investors making transactions before that date will still have to follow the existing rules and should not treat the proposed reform as permission to disregard a previously made disposal of assets.

The proposed relaxations would address a long-standing problem in DeFi taxation, but the draft defines the boundaries of which assets, transactions and participants qualify. These conditions explain why the proposal may simplify an ordinary loan while leaving a more complex strategy with multiple separate taxable events.

Transferring funds can generate income before any cash arrives

Under HMRC’s existing lending guidance, the question is whether the lender or liquidity provider transfers ownership of the tokens. The answer depends on the contract and the actual rights created by that arrangement.

If the recipient is free to dispose of the tokens, HMRC treats this as a strong indication that ownership has passed to another party. A restriction preventing the recipient from disposing of them indicates the opposite.

As a result, the transaction may constitute a disposal. An investor expecting to receive the tokens back later would have to value the rights received and calculate the gain before receiving any money to pay taxes.

A simple illustrative example demonstrates this mismatch. Someone buys tokens for £5,000 and later deposits them into a transaction when their value reaches £12,000, and that transaction qualifies as a disposal under current rules.

Ignoring fees and other adjustments, the difference is £7,000, even though the investor received no cash. The final tax amount depends on deductions, losses, rates and the actual legal treatment, not just on this illustrative gain.

If the tokens subsequently fall in value, the earlier taxable event does not automatically disappear. The subsequent loss must be recognized and settled under the applicable rules, possibly in a different tax year.

The return of the tokens can lead to further calculations because the lender exchanged the rights under the arrangement for the received assets. HMRC’s existing guidance on loan repayment explains how this treatment depends on the original transaction.

As a result, the reform affects both timing and paperwork. The investor’s economic risk may remain within the loan, while the tax system treats a disposal and a newly acquired right.

Moving tokens between wallets owned by the same person is an entirely different case, since the beneficial owner may remain unchanged. Treating every on-chain transfer as a taxable transaction would be wrong even under the current system.

In the DeFi context, the question comes down to what the investor gives up and what they receive under the arrangement. On-chain fund movements serve as evidence of events, and the governing rights determine their legal character.

A transaction tracking tool alone cannot establish those rights. When deciding how a transfer should be reported, loans are repaid, returned, and an option to use the deposited tokens is granted.