In This Article
Chainflip vault loses $4.86 million

According to blockchain trackers Onchain Lens and AMLBot, on November 21 Chainflip lost about $4.86 million in ETH and stablecoins from its Ethereum vault.

Onchain Lens reported that as a result of the withdrawal from the cross-chain swap protocol’s vault, 520.2 ETH, 3.25 million USDC, and 758,000 USDT were taken. According to the tracker, the transaction contained a valid signature from the vault’s aggregate signing key, which increases the likelihood of key compromise.

The transaction record provided by Onchain Lens shows a transfer at 07:10:59 UTC. It lists three assets leaving the same contract and going to the same destination address. The contract listed in the record matches the Ethereum vault in Chainflip’s documentation.

Based on the dollar amounts listed in the transaction record, the initial ETH transfer amounted to approximately $850,000. USDC made up the largest portion of the withdrawn funds — about $3.25 million — while USDT accounted for roughly $757,000. Together, the two stablecoins represented about 82% of the estimated losses.

Chainflip provides a service that allows users to swap assets between blockchains. The project lists separate vault addresses for supported networks, with the Ethereum vault listed separately from the contracts used for deposits and swaps. The transfers identified by Onchain Lens were made from the Ethereum vault itself.

The signing key matters for how the vault authorizes outgoing transactions. Chainflip’s whitepaper describes a system in which validators cooperate to produce a single signature for a vault transaction. Onchain Lens pointed to the valid signature as evidence for its key-compromise theory.

The signature confirms that the transaction passed the vault’s authorization check. How the signature was obtained remains unclear.

Most of the funds passed through Tornado Cash

AMLBot reported that both stablecoins were converted to ETH on Uniswap within four minutes of the withdrawal, before their issuers could take any action. The blockchain analytics firm said almost the entire amount was deposited into Tornado Cash within nine minutes. The mixer pools deposits, making it difficult to trace incoming funds and subsequent withdrawals.

Onchain Lens traced about 2,909 ETH, which at the time of the report amounted to roughly $4.75 million, in connection with transactions involving the mixer. The ETH traced at that point included funds obtained from swapping the stablecoins. Thus, the $4.75 million figure describes a later movement of funds already included in the withdrawal estimate.

“We believe the money laundering was planned and automated from start to finish,” AMLBot said in a follow-up post. The firm estimated the entire sequence of actions took less than 10 minutes and said it continues to track the movement of the funds.

Chainflip suspended Ethereum deposits after an August attempt

In an August update, Chainflip reported containing an exploit attempt related to cross-network messaging and refunds on the Ethereum network. The team suspended deposits and quoting on Ethereum, Arbitrum, and Tron networks while investigating.

Chainflip said the exploit attempt did not result in any loss of user funds and that the network update was ready roughly 24 hours after the initial report.

Announcing the update, Chainflip said it would clear the queue of swaps held during the pause before resuming quoting. The team said pending swaps would either be processed automatically or refunded.

In September, compensation was paid from surplus USDC

On September 12, Chainflip lost 736,442 USDT on Tron. Chainflip attributed the loss to specifics of transaction memo handling in its Tron integration. Six liquidity provider withdrawals were paid twice, leaving the Tron vault short of the USDT it owed liquidity providers.

In an update issued three days after the relaunch, Chainflip said it would first return swaps in other networks. The firm planned to close open orders and wind down lending positions tied to Tron USDT, record the debt owed to each liquidity provider, and zero out the corresponding balances before settling them.

Subsequently, validators approved Proposal 008. The plan provided for returning all Tron USDT that could be withdrawn from the vault and crediting the remaining amount in USDC to affected liquidity providers at a one-to-one ratio. According to Chainflip’s accounting as of September 18, the amount covered by the proposal was $748,935.16.

The same proposal noted that at the time, the Ethereum vault held just over $1.08 million in surplus USDC. Chainflip attributed the vault surplus to several sources, including excess funds from gas fee accounting and deposits sent to expired channels or the wrong network.